• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Sicily Trattoria

### OUR STORY

At Sicily Trattoria, located in the heart of Cape Coral, we embrace the rich culinary traditions of Italy. Our menu celebrates authentic flavors, featuring thin-crust pizzas and delectable pasta dishes made from fresh ingredients. Diners appreciate the casual, inviting atmosphere, perfect for families and groups, with options for takeout and delivery. Our enthusiasm for quality shines through in every dish, from the mouthwatering Eggplant Rollotini to the fan-favorite Spaghetti con Aglio e Olio. As customer reviews highlight, our commitment to exceptional service and a warm environment makes Sicily Trattoria a beloved gem in the community, where every meal feels like a slice of home.

Sicily Trattoria: Reviews & Ratings

Darlene D.
Darlene D.

My husband and I have been going to this restaurant for years and absolutely love the food. The service is good and so is the atmosphere. I highly recommend this gem of a restaurant.

Linda E.
Linda E.

We stopped here and I thought I would try pasta but everyone in there was eating pizza so changed our minds and decided to try a supreme pizza. That was a very good decision! The thin crust pizza was perfectly cooked and with just the right amount of toppings it was done to perfection. However, we will be returning to try some homemade noodles with pesto sauce very soon!

Gretchen M.
Gretchen M.

Pizza was amazing. Not a super thick crust which is the way I like it. The chef was funny. The price was much better than the other pizza place we tried.

Jerry C.
Jerry C.

This was the 1st time going to Sicily Trattoria since they moved downtown from our neighborhood on Pine Island road years ago. I am happy to report that we enjoyed the Italian food with the exception of the bread. My wife had Tortellini with artichoke and mushroom in light cream sauce which she enjoyed very much. I judge an Italian restaurant the 1st time by its Spaghetti and meatballs in tomato sauce again very good. We each had a glass of the lowest priced Chianti wine which was also good. For an Italian restaurant we did not care for the bread, to us it was not Italian bread with a nice crust. We are even on our option on the Tiramisu, not terrible but also not as good as we have had locally. Over all we would strongly recommend Sicily Trattoria. They have done a nice job since they have moved.

Franck W.
Franck W.

I am out of town so I will qualify what I am saying here but it's probably the best pizza in Cape Coral. It's not the Napoliteab style (duh!) but it's very very good Go check them out I recommend order ahead if you picking up. They can be very busy . Or if you are like me sit at the bar and enjoy a drink

Angel M.
Angel M.

They have the best chicken soup and broccoli and cheese soup around. They have good service and the environment is quaint. The owners are working there all the time and are very helpful and nice. Definitely would recommend.

K A.
K A.

Visiting for a few days and new to the area. Found the reviews on Yelp, called the resturant for take out. The staff was patient with me on the phone, made a few suggestions and were spot on with the time our food would be ready. We had a pizza, large salad (fresh with great dressing), a side of meatballs and garlic knots. I always order meatballs at new places, right or wrong it's a litmus test on whether we'll come back for pasta. A manager came over and suggested wine choices for me. Great food and service. Will be going back one night this week for pasta!

Debbie N.
Debbie N.

Love this nook in Cape Coral. My husband and I enjoyed dinner. I had the Linguine and Clams, with white wine sauce and hubby enjoyed Eggplant Parmesan. Great service from Manny. He is attentive and very personably.

Angelina F.
Angelina F.

This is one of my favorite pizza places in town! How lucky am I to live with in walking distance . I can't believe I actually haven't reviewed them yet so here we go! It's I nice little spot with cute red lighting to set a vibe. I believe it's a family who owns it and the staff is very nice! I'm not sure if they're family as well. I usually get one of threes pizza when I come because I'm pretty basic. You can never go wrong with a classic cheese, I sometimes even add sausage. Or if I'm feeling something different I get the Bianca but sub broccoli for sausage. The margarita is also very good. The pizza is perfectly crisp with no flop at all! I've had their pastas a few times too and also delicious! If you love pizza come here you'll be very satisfied.

Location

Welcome to Sicily Trattoria, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Cape Coral. Located at 1211 Cape Coral Pkwy E, this charming trattoria invites you to indulge in a culinary journey through classic Italian flavors, all while enjoying a casual and welcoming atmosphere.

Sicily Trattoria prides itself on offering a diverse menu that caters to a variety of dietary preferences, featuring numerous vegetarian options and dishes that will delight even the most discerning palates. With the convenience of reservations, delivery, and takeout, this trattoria makes it easy to enjoy a taste of Italy, whether you're dining solo or with friends and family.

  • Signature Dishes: Dive into indulgent Sicily Dinners including the flavorful Parmigiana, served with a side salad of your choice. For a lighter option, try the Spaghetti con Aglio e Olio, perfectly sautéed with fresh garlic and olive oil.
  • Appetizers: Don't miss the delightful Eggplant Rollotini, stuffed with ricotta and spinach, or the tangy Caponata, a delightful cold eggplant dish that bursts with flavor.
  • Pizza: The highlight for many patrons is undoubtedly the pizza, renowned for its thin crust and perfectly balanced toppings. Countless visitors rave about the supreme pizza, which leaves a lasting impression.

Many customers have shared their fond experiences at Sicily Trattoria, with one patron, Darlene D., praising the restaurant as a gem with excellent food and a pleasant atmosphere. Franck W. went so far as to declare it probably the best pizza in Cape Coral, encouraging others to try it for themselves, especially if they’re keen on a delightful drink at the bar.

While the menu is robust, pairs well with wine, and the dishes come highly recommended, it’s the warm, inviting ambiance that makes Sicily Trattoria stand out. Enjoy a meal outdoors on the patio or relax in the quiet, cozy interior—perfect for a lunch break or a family dinner. The restaurant is also family-friendly, making it a fantastic choice for children.

In conclusion, if you’re looking for a casual dining experience filled with rich Italian flavors, Sicily Trattoria is worth a visit. With a commitment to quality ingredients and heartfelt service, this trattoria promises to deliver on all fronts, making each meal a delightful experience.

To make a reservation or learn more, give them a call at (239) 945-7285.